meems wrote:
It's so hard to define by specific actions because it's about how a person makes you feel, which is, I think, why it's easy to dismiss or call unfair. It's also frustrating because if someone calls another person creepy, there's not a lot the person can do to prove they aren't creepy.
Very good point.
Creepiness is in the eye of the beholder. A person may be creepy to one person and perfectly acceptable to another.
The sense that a particular person is creepy is a reaction to that person. It is not an inherent attribute of the person. If I sit at a table, staring blankly across the room and another person finds this behavior creepy, that is their own valid response to my behavior. It may be wrong and it may be an over reaction, but that doesn't change that person's reaction. So finding another person creepy is a state of mind existing in the person doing the reaction. It is not an attribute of the person who is seen as creepy.
I think one thing that makes a person come across as creepy is when their behavior is unpredictable and their intentions are difficult to assess. For example, someone who keeps appearing at your place of work, near your home, near your friends's home etc, yet will not ask for a date is creepy because it is unclear what that person's intentions are. Do they want the pleasure of your company or are they planning to kill you? It can be hard to determine.
A person who, however innocently, fumbles at doing the common social rituals of expressing interest and asking for a date, can come across as creepy if their intentions are unclear.
I had a crush on a girl in college. We had gone on one sort of date. I liked to hang around her when I could, even if there wasn't a good reason. We were both in the theatre department and there is a sort of artificial intimacy that develops in theatre where everyone must work closely to put on a show. At one point we were both working backstage and there was a lull in the work. She was seated on a table. I sat on the table, leaning my back against her's. I was hoping she would find this physical closeness appealing and would lean back against me. Instead she launched herself off the table and got away from me.
I had seen others behave in this kind of physically close manner and hoped I could impersonate someone who was comfortable with this sort of casual physical intimacy. What I didn't understand is that in order to engage in this kind of physical closeness, I would have needed to develop a deeper friendship with her than I had. Because our friendship was not at the necessary level, I grossly overstepped her personal space and she had every right to find my behavior inappropriate.
My point is that because I was trying to bypass the difficult process of developing intimacy with this woman, I behaved in an inappropriately intimate manner. Because I had no clue how to how to form a closer friendship and I wanted to force that friendship into existence, I did things that, while innocent, made her uncertain of what she could expect from me. I wanted to act out a kind of relationship I had not done the work to develop. My intentions might have been decent, but she had no way to be certain that I would behave decently. I assume she thought I was creepy. She certainly had every right to.
Anyway, that's my long way of saying I think unpredictable and inappropriate behavior, however well intentioned, makes a person come across as creepy.
_________________
Never let the weeds get higher than the garden,
Always keep a sapphire in your mind.
(Tom Waits "Get Behind the Mule")