I have often found that actually addressing counter-arguments is a good way to lose a debate online because it makes me look like I am going on the defensive, but I will foolishly do so now because I believe in honest discussion and I feel that you deserve a real answer rather than the kind of offensive move that would let me score "points" in my favor.
This will get rather longer than I'd like, but please understand it is my way of showing that I take your objections seriously and feel that they deserve a full and thorough treatment. I'm kind of analytical and obsessive that way.
Quote:
What straw man?
If you will read Skahthic's post I think you will find that he is attacking a position I do not hold. He seems to think that I made a generalization that all or most Aspies don't bathe. This is the straw man I refer to. I said nothing of the kind. Anyone who wishes to satisfy himself as to what I did or did not say may read my first post on the subject, and the second, which addresses precisely the same objection.
Quote:
You implied that Aspies don't care for their outward appearance without implicating NT people into the equation who may not care for their appearance anymore than said Aspies; got the stats from both sides? Only including one side is a generalisation.
Yes I do think it is more common for us to violate social norms, including those regarding outward appearance and hygiene, and that it is ok to break some of those rules, as I do myself, but that bathing is not one of the rules that it is "ok" to break.
It's interesting that you think I said that ASers care less about our appearance than NTs. Did I really say that? Or did you assume that someone who makes the supposed error of wearing white after labor day cares less about his appearance? I think that on the contrary it is possible to be very self aware of ones appearance while playing by different rules.
Now you are also apparently demanding that I produce statistics to prove that ASers are more likely to violate certain social norms re: appearance and hygiene than are NTs. That's like asking me to produce statistics proving that elephants have trunks. It's obvious, unneccessary and basically a cheap debate tactic. I don't feel like playing that game with you.
Quote:
All you said is that some “Aspies” don’t shower to your arbitrary standards and this somehow “harms” people; conversely, there are plenty of NT people that don’t conform to my standards (or yours), but I don’t give a damn if they soak themselves in fragrant alcohol and they give me a migraine if I’m anywhere near them.
Having a shower doesn’t necessarily mean you won’t smell (you’ll probably need to baste yourself in chemicals); nor cleaning your teeth doesn’t guarantee “fresh” smelling breath (the common sinus infection for example).
You say that NTs also have an offensive odor at times due to wearing excessive cologne. Well of course. I don't quite see the point of bringing this up, but if you mean to say that this makes it ok for anyone else to go around with an offensive odor because they don't bathe, I suppose I disagree with you about that.
You also say that showering and brushing do not necessarily guarantee a pleasing aroma. Well of course not. But not showering eventually guarantees a foul odor, even if you are one of those rare people who can skip a day or two without anyone noticing it will eventually catch up to you.
thanks to anyone who actually read this far