A guide to enjoying the film Noah (For A.S. folk)
An atheist makes a movie based on a Biblical story, changes the story almost completely, and people applaud his creativity and condemn people who are offended.
How enlightened society has become ! !
^since when has any story been adapted from the written work without a massive re-write? Did you watch The Passion of the Christ? Do you realize that much of that movie is not in the Bible? Why was no one up in arms over that? This is just one more example of how a certain flavor of christianity tries to play the "atheists are out to destroy us" just because the director is an atheist.
And how about the TV movie of Noah's Ark with Jon Voigt? You know, the one where Noah was a citizen of Sodom? Or Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat? The Ten Commandments? Jesus Christ, Superstar? The Last Temptation of Christ? Son of God? Pretty much any movie that portrays Jesus as a white dude? The History Channel's The Bible was rife with inaccuracy. There are very, very few biblically based movies that stay true to the original. I don't really understand why Noah is suddenly the most horrible thing ever. I have not seen it, but I doubt that any part of the movie is spent trying to convince people to become atheists, so why should you care? Maybe if the title was something like "The Thorough and Biblically Accurate Account of Noah, his Interaction with God, and Big D@mn Boat" I would understand the offense. Even if anyone involved with the movie came out and said that it was accurate or that it was intended to downplay people's belief in god, I could understand it.
Seriously, if you don't like it, just don't watch it. It is that simple.
The Ten Commandments, don't get me started! Still I love that movie.
Prof_Pretorius
Veteran
Joined: 20 Aug 2006
Age: 68
Gender: Male
Posts: 7,520
Location: Hiding in the attic of the Arkham Library
The point you are missing is that it is one thing to change details of a Biblical story, and something else to change the nature of the person in the story. The DeMille version of the Ten Commandments might be a re-telling of the story, BUT all the people are shown accurately. Moses is shown as man who changes from a popular Egyptian to an outcast who realizes he is a Hebrew. The problem with "Noah" is that the BASIC details of the characters have been altered.
_________________
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow. I feel my fate in what I cannot fear. I learn by going where I have to go. ~Theodore Roethke
sonofghandi
Veteran
Joined: 17 Apr 2007
Age: 47
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,540
Location: Cleveland, OH (and not the nice part)
And the point you seem to be missing is that it is a high budget Hollywood movie, not a historical documentary or a film meant to convert the ungodly hordes.
_________________
"The surest way to corrupt a youth is to instruct him to hold in higher esteem those who think alike than those who think differently" -Nietzsche
The problem with the film is that outside influences, which had no financial or artistic say in the movie, dictated the process of the production, IMPOSING religious views on society again, at the same time they re telling society that Christianity is "under attack," the Christian groups pitch a hissy fit and demand their say in the final outcome of the movie. Movie now not worth the time of day, IMO.
Did they?
lostonearth35
Veteran
Joined: 5 Jan 2010
Age: 52
Gender: Female
Posts: 13,896
Location: On a planet where I don't belong.
Fine, if you want to see a movie that tells the Biblical story about how a god who is supposed to love everyone but decides to kill most of them, including babies and small children, and all the poor innocent animals that didn't make it on the Ark, and if you can ignore the message that everyone needs a mate or else they're incomplete and will therefor perish, refuse to question how two of every single land animal, including tiny insects, are managed to be kept alive on one huge ship without killing or eating each other, or how they provided the food and space and bathroom needs for them, or have the intelligence to wonder about all the trees and plants that somehow didn't get destroyed in the flood, or even why something round and boat-shaped was measured in square cubits, then by all means go do it. But don't tell me I have to see it.
Don't wanna, don't haveta, ain't gonna.
I remember how Pinocchio got swallowed up by a big whale. No whale, not even a blue whale could never swallow a person whole because their throat is actually quite small for their size. But that was okay, because it was just a story and wasn't really true. But Jonah was also swallowed by a whale and we're supposed to believe that it was true. And that'll probably be the next movie they'll make. ![]()
Don't wanna, don't haveta, ain't gonna.
I remember how Pinocchio got swallowed up by a big whale. No whale, not even a blue whale could never swallow a person whole because their throat is actually quite small for their size. But that was okay, because it was just a story and wasn't really true. But Jonah was also swallowed by a whale and we're supposed to believe that it was true. And that'll probably be the next movie they'll make.
You make the mistake of assuming that God sees earthly demise as the end of human existence.
