Still: unpleasant and sad.
The unreasonable expectations and extremely negative self-image sounds like depression.
It seems to me that your apprehensions are not unreasonable. He is on a path toward many negative potentials.
But it also seems to me that you should lay this burden down. He doesn't want your help. He doesn't want your company. You should let him go.
I agree with all this -- except then why does he keep pinging me, getting in touch? It's like skype is the outer limit of what he can tolerate socially, with specific people, so he hangs on to that as a lifeline. Ever since I've known him, he's talked very deliberately about "getting his social activity", like it's a vitamin that he knows he has to take. And he's (unnecessarily, I think) ashamed of not having a rich real-life social life. He could have one if he wanted to and could stand it, but there are many barriers. In general he just finds friends, even old friends, too perilous and exhausting. And I take it he's had this conversation many, many, many times, how he doesn't reciprocate or show any particular pleasure in friendship, and (turns out) is extremely sensitive to such complaints. I mean he's been hurt a lot -- a lot -- but it's like there's no solid understanding that people are sometimes reacting to how he's treating them, not just being randomly horrible at him.
I mean I recognize that I'm painting a picture here of a wholly unpleasant person, which is not how things are at all (obviously). But jesus, it does seem to be most of the weight lately. Over a long lately. Again, there are plenty of stressors, but he seems to think they're unique to him and everyone else is out having a wonderful, navigable life full of riches he can't have.
It is very disturbing, and in my experience not particularly safe. There's a national border between us, though, and will be for a long while if not forever.
I've wondered that myself, about what's drawing me, and actually I don't think I'm being drawn to damage. These guys present themselves as pretty together and accomplished, with rich family lives, all kinds of stuff, and it all seems highly plausible to me. When I met my ex-husband, he had a great job and had been in it for years, was moving up, seemed to have hobbies, talked a great game. It was mostly lies and fantasy, and he lost the job within a year of our daughter's birth. (It was a tough job to lose, too, the kind of government thing where you have to crash and burn for a solid year before they can pry you out.) He still lies about that one, claims he quit, that they drove him out. And they're all very bright guys with excellent academic backgrounds (actually my ex-husband lied some about his, and led me to believe he had a degree he didn't, along with a bunch of other stuff). I'm sure there are many who'd say, well, if they're really all that, why are they in that crap situation, the story stinks; but I also know a lot of people who really are topnotch and just doing things their own way, and are happy and successful that way. They just aren't conventionally successful -- or they spend the figurative 40 years in the wilderness before some company or university buys them as creative talent.
What's drawn me to all of them is that they seem fun, initially, with interesting things to talk about, and amenable to ordinary friendship, apart from being attractive one way or another. And the most disconcerting thing is finding that actually they harbor this whole ranking system in their heads, and despise themselves and envy and loathe me, and -- weirdest of all -- actually scorn me for all sorts of things. Being a single mom, having to work hard, not having much money -- it's like they're outraged that I don't see my own position low on the totem pole and react with proportionate shame and hatred of the society that oppresses me so. Because actually I've never felt that way. When I have noticed those rules, they've just seemed to me dumb and highly ignorable. And when the guys realize that this is what's going on with me, they're just embarrassed and start talking about how much more secure I am than they are. After a while they hate me for it. I can think of only one who might have had the perspective and sense of humor to skip the hating part -- he was already well into competition and measuring-up and despair over what I'd think of him -- but I'll never know, because he killed himself first.
My guess, actually, is that they're drawn to me because I don't embarrass them as a girlfriend and they believe they're superior to me socially, they're not afraid that way. And I miss that dynamic as it's happening. I don't know that "less damaged guys" have ever been interested in me. It seems to me that in many ways I'm probably outside their world: I show up with no family except the one I made, I'm deaf to or unreceptive to the usual gender-role stuff, I'm tactless and extremely perceptive of lots of things, I don't particularly value all sorts of conventional markers of success, and I've always lived as an artist. As I've gotten older, some of these guys have sought me out as a sort of confessor, maybe because I don't make the sort of judgments their wives do. They seem to find it necessary to tell me that I'm not like other women, that I scare them because I'm so much smarter than they are, that they wouldn't have the balls to live as I do, and that they're not attracted to me. And once they unburden themselves they just want to escape back into their lives with a nice wife who takes care of them, and a large family that helps to protect them from the world, and children who validate their existence.
Yeah. I don't know -- it's certainly not that I go looking for people to take care of, and in fact I spend a good deal of time at the outset of relationships talking about how it's specifically not what I'm after doing. Not to be gender-boring, but I think most of them started out truly nice and decent people, and have been casualties of what men do to men, the insistence that a very narrow way of being is good and manly, everything else to be despised and destroyed.
This all sounds eerily familiar. I recognize two of my exes in your description of your friend/ex. In the end, I had to walk away from both of them. One of the splits was an amicable, mutual walking-away, and we're still friends, but only communicate once or twice a year, if that. The other split was antagonistic and hostile, and I did not stay in touch with him, but I imagine he is still merrily busy being miserable and making everyone around him miserable, too. I put better than 10 years into each of those relationships, only the first two of which were actually what I would consider mutually-rewarding. The rest of the time was me functioning as their emotional sponge, while they were locked up tight in a Zip-Loc bag, so no chance of there being any sort of equal partnership. I functioned as a sugar mama, a mommy, and a shrink with zero benefit to myself.
I also had a girlfriend once upon a time who was possibly bipolar and put me through absolute living hell for nearly 10 years before I walked away from that, too. Basically, I decided I wasn't going to hang around to watch any of them go down in a ball of flames. I satisfied myself that *I* couldn't help them any more than I already had (if I had helped at all), and there was a huge chance that I would end up going down in that ball of flames with them.
I'm one of the most empathetic people I've ever encountered (literally, if I see someone crying, I will cry, too), but I could never understand what was the attraction for these people to live in negativity 98% of the time. I know it's a chemical imbalance that causes depression (and I've had bouts of it myself, but they are situational, not chronic), so I know what a deep, dark hole depression can be, but damn.....in some ways they seemed to thoroughly enjoy the doom and gloom. I am aware that it really does take a lot of work (and, in some chases, medication) to pull oneself out of that hole. It is also absolutely true that the only person who can do that work is the person suffering from the depression. Anyone other than a very skilled psychologist/psychiatrist is likely to merely enable the behavior.
Even though I couldn't talk these partners/friends into seeing a psych professional, I ended up spending years going to therapy so that *I* didn't go nuts from dealing with my depressive partners/friends. In that process, I became aware that I was, at least to some extent, being an enabler, patting them on the head and saying "there, there" soothingly, which, as it turns out, is probably all they really ever wanted from me. Some tough love would probably have ultimately been more helpful to them, but I didn't feel qualified to be the one to dispense it.
I do know that people who suffer from depression can be very adept at masking it for short-to-moderate periods of time. Which is how I personally keep getting involved with those sorts. I don't know what to do to avoid attracting this type of person in the future, but I would really like to avoid any more such relationships, whether they be platonic friendships or romantic involvements. Maybe I'm misreading depressive tendencies as worldly wisdom, and since I am, above all, attracted to intelligence, all I got from their vibe was the "wisdom" part - dunno, I'll let you know if I ever figure it out!
So, yeah, bottom line, I totally get what you're going through, and I feel for you. Literally.
I am sorry that it's been this way for you and I hope you run into a confident free spirit without all this baggage and hit it off. I know you are not seeking that, but you deserve some happiness and support.
Thank you, Adamantium and Eureka.
I think it's deliberate, the lying, but without much foresight or conviction. My ex-husband once told me that he'd deliberately deceived me at the start, told me what he thought I wanted to hear. Certainly the ongoing deceptions are deliberate, dressed as "subversion"; even my daughter finds it uncomfortable when he tries to get her to do naughty things just to break the rules. (This guy's a child therapist now, mind.) And the ex/friend once went on an extended rant/monologue about some girl expecting honesty -- how, he demanded, could it ever be possible to get a girlfriend without lying? I don't know. Maybe it's justified as defensive. It does go along with the defensive-crouch belief that everyone else is lying/stealing/whatever too, and IME these people can just explode if you just blink at them and say, um, no, I don't do that. Then it's all about how you're judging them, followed by a sort of extended whine about how fortunate you are that you don't have to do these things, but they do. The ex/friend also tried to get me to lie on his behalf -- he was having trouble finding a job, wanted to invent something to cover a gap and asked whether I'd say I'd been his manager at a bookstore. I didn't really react well to that -- the last thing I need, as an employer, is lying applicants in the mix; also, just no; also, why would I put my own reputation on the line like that, given how much responsibility I carry? But, you know, employers, evil because rich so I should lie in solidarity; also, he was only joking but I certainly showed my colors; also, other friend would've done it and therefore loved him better; etc. All of this happened during a vacation I was paying for, mind, and which he managed to trash completely with his moods and nastiness.
I remember discovering that my then-husband owed his first ex-wife $9K. He'd simply decided to ignore the decree. Most of the stories he'd told me about her and what went on in their marriage and career were lies. It turns out that's fairly common. But he'd painted her as a needy leech who'd demanded his help with all sorts of things, and how he walked out broke because he paid for part of her grad ed...not so much.
The one who killed himself also lied like a rug, though he was starting to be honest at the end; his brother filled in some of the rest of the story. But one thing he wasn't apt to do was trash his ex-wife.
I think actually my problem's just in not leaving soon enough. Partly out of fear of hastiness, want to be sure I understand what's happening. These guys also have abandonment stories out the wazoo, how cruelly people have treated them, so if you're dumb and sympathetic you try not to be that person. Especially if there's some element of authenticity in what they're saying. But yeah, most people ditch quickly for a reason. Then it's a big shock -- people will leave you over nothing, you said a wrong string of words, people are horrible....Of course, the one time that I did say 'can't do this, sorry', the guy was dead five days later.
The skills-envy and hatred...yeah, it's about jealousy. And the scorn because, I don't know, they've got some left over after being scornful of themselves. I think this is really what it comes down to, these are guys who detest themselves. The world is divided into allies and enemies.
I get that very bright, talented guys who aren't much for ladder-climbing and toys-collecting take tremendous abuse from the world from the time they're small, especially if they aren't much good at sports. (Ex/friend's brother played football for a top academic university, had letters galore. Ex/friend was not on sports teams and instead got beat up routinely by 'friends'.) I don't find skittishness, wariness, been-abused behaviors all that surprising. Nor depression, bipolarity, AS. I mean it's not a recipe for self-confidence. I don't actually know why I have the self-confidence that I do, and always have had -- it's just that I've always had a very strong, visceral sense of what I've wanted to do, and not seen why I shouldn't, if I was able and people would let me. All sorts of people have found me maddening for exactly that reason -- they've gone years not doing things because they were convinced it wasn't possible or no one would let them, and they made peace with that, and then here comes me and just does it. Or they've slaved for years to be reasonably decent at something and then along comes me to try it for fun and it turns out I'm great at it. And then instead of sticking around for the glory, for which they'd give anything, I'll say, "that was fun, but not really that much fun after all," and abandon it. Never noticing, either, how hard they've worked. It makes people crazy, further demonstration of how the world isn't fair and it's like they're there solely to be the goat. It's not like I can say, "Hey, come watch me play tennis, watch me suck radically," because that apparently doesn't make up for it. Nor does "Hey, come watch me stay up working till 4 am and function like a zombie the next day because I have no choice" because then there's this mopey stuff about how at least I can function and have things to do.
Happiness and support would be awesome. I have trouble complaining, though, because really, I've done miraculously well and been lucky in necessary spots. Am healthy. Have beautiful, smart, nice, healthy kid who clearly has her own engine, and who can go to college without coming out drowned in debt. Have house. Have friends. Have career, well-compensated in money and respect, reasonably enjoyable. Have apple trees with apples. And, after cleaning out my house over the last few weeks, recognize I've got as much stuff as I should need for the rest of my life, more or less. It's also been sort of astonishing to recognize that I have in fact got my whole life here. Meaningful things from childhood, college, early adulthood, grad school, travels and work here and abroad, marriage, motherhood...photos and mementos and recording from family members now long dead, and from their parents...stories told through financial and legal records, stories told as stories, correspondence...and my daughter's whole life so far. Things she made, stories I wrote for her, her various clothes and costumes and toys, school notebooks, diaries. It's quite a lot, even though I thought I'd been throwing it away the whole time.
I've also...and this is new to me...I've realized over the last year or so that I've become an elder, with responsibilities. Young people -- they don't seem so young to me, I don't feel that much older, but I am -- are respectful, and listen differently now, because I know things just by virtue of having been around and done things for a long time. So I have to be a little careful in how I talk to them. But it's like showing up somewhere and being told, oh, over here, ma'am, there's a seat for you, you belong at this table. When I'd had no idea anyone knew I existed.
Oh, I should do some work.
So, is your ex autistic? He sounds like a bit of a jerk either way, though. The business about lying - some people do seem to function that way. I fall for it every time; I'm gullible.
Do I understand correctly that you own a bookstore? If so, that's cool. We only have one independent bookseller left in my city. The big boxes came in and took out the smaller competition. But on-line is such a killer; the prices are hard to beat. Anyway I worked at a bookstore for almost 10 years in the '90s. Best job I ever had.
It certainly seems that way, and though he doesn't much like the idea he agrees.
Nope, no bookstore-owning for me, though I used to work in them. Indies, used, chain, you name it. Can't afford to anymore. The best surviving stores I know are all used (was in Chicago recently and meant to go to Myopic, but never managed it). But it's a totally different business model. The indie new stores I know are just so desperate to survive now that they're aggressive with the handselling, try to turn themselves into community centers, all kinds of things. Actually I have to admit I don't often buy books anymore -- have enough to last me the decade, and I find the stores disheartening. I walk in, am overwhelmed and depressed by the number of books, and walk out feeling that the best thing I could do would be to stop writing. Enough books, enough people jumping up saying me me me, my story, my book, my name.
Yeah, but it's that way with everything - so many people. Each one unique and should be appreciated. But the good ones always stand out. It's like they say in sports, you have to focus on your own game.
I hope your ex goes to his doctor. It's not as bad as he might think. Once you realize that it's just like any other ailment and start listing the symptoms to the doctor it's like any visit. I always prepare a lot before visiting and know what issues I want to talk to them about and specific things that are being effected in my life.
Yeah, it's the same here with independent booksellers, there are several used book stores that are doing okay. Sometimes it's the best way to find out-of-print stuff.
Yeah, I hope he will too. There's all kinds of resistance but he really needs help with some of this stuff.
The funny thing is how the things I'm okay with change as I get older. There are all sorts of things I won't put up with anymore, but at the same time there's a lot more tolerance in certain areas. I don't think I've ever been involved with anyone as controlling as this guy is -- wanted to control, really pretty closely, the manner and content and timing of all communication; how and when we had sex was very rigid and constricted (and he really had to be in charge, right down to how he wanted me to kiss him), everything about his environment had to be just so, and it was palpable how he had to constrain that impulse when he stayed at my house...you could see it was driving him nuts. He wanted to control what and how and why I ate, how things went at restaurants...and yet I was aware that it wasn't about controlling me, it was about controlling his world. There was this deep sense of insecurity to do with not having any control...and yet he's one of the most aggressively controlling people I've ever met. It just isn't enough, he can't make things safe and comfortable enough. For him. Anything can (and does) wander in and set off all kinds of intolerable vibes. There's fear and panic all over the place. And you know, I get all that. I don't live it, and there are lines I'll draw, but I see it. It's just when we get to the point of "I have to control when and how we're friends; friends means that in exchange for knowing I feel certain things about you, you just do for me and understand this won't be reciprocal" that I have to get off the bus, because I'm not a...service module, or something. I'd come back later, when things are better, but I don't know when there's a "later when things are better."
I've known a few people like that over the years and I have very little patience for this behaviour. It is really creepy to make other people participate in a little fantasy world where we all pretend things are the way s/he envisions them.
I know about obsessive behaviour to ward off anxiety. It's bad enough to let yourself get away with personal compulsions, but to drag other people into them is just, well, like I said, creepy.
Is that what it is, do you think? An effort to make people live in one's fantasy world? It hadn't occurred to me. I do remember he once said something very insistent about needing his mother to live in *his* world -- after the usual sort of argument with a mom in which she's Just Not Getting It -- and it struck me as odd.
Actually this is a major problem of mine -- I don't notice other people's anxiety, and it doesn't occur to me (I'm apparently pretty loose, which is surprising to me). So I'll misread all kinds of things that are anxiety-related.
I was with a man like this for 9 years. If anything deviated from his vision of how things should be he would totally lose it. I think it's emotionally abusive behaviour when one tries to control the other's experience of reality.
It was. I stayed because I had no money, my stepfather wouldnt let me move back home and I was too depressed to effect an escape. I saved up money for 6 months prior to leaving and only when I had an apartment did I tell him.
I've known a few people like that over the years and I have very little patience for this behaviour. It is really creepy to make other people participate in a little fantasy world where we all pretend things are the way s/he envisions them.
I know about obsessive behaviour to ward off anxiety. It's bad enough to let yourself get away with personal compulsions, but to drag other people into them is just, well, like I said, creepy.
Hey Ann, thanks for this thought. Eventually I did some looking around -- I hadn't thought of it in terms of compulsions, so I was looking at OCD stuff. Found a thing called relationship OCD, and was like, jesus, this is just about every single thing that happened when the relationship fell apart. I spent two solid months being told daily what was wrong with me and why the relationship would never work (this was a guy who'd been on a full-court press to get me to move closer to him a couple months before), plus getting long emails about how I wasn't being told that things were wrong with me. It was a total whack-a-mole scene: I'd say, okay, that makes no actual sense because; and then he'd shift ground to something else; and I'd say look, do you want to break up? because if so, why not just say so, and besides this is being horrible to live through, I don't get what you're after; and he'd say no, no, I don't want to break up but I don't see how this can work, tell me how it can work, and would be earnest about it. And then the next day it'd be like talking to another person, and I'd get really angry stuff about not understanding how hard everything is for him. Meanwhile, I was becoming miserably depressed. All the things he managed to find as flaws were things I had absolutely no control over, too.
It really sucked. And I recognize there wasn't anything I could've done, and that it wouldn't have mattered who I was -- it's been this way in all his relationships, they're cruising along, things become awful, he pulls the plug, and the woman's all, "what? are you sure?" His rationalization's that he's just been smarter than all these women are in refusing to go through chronic agonies.
Given my age, I have been in quite a few relationships, and the viewpoint I now have on whether to continue or not is reduced to this one essential issue (in my view): Is this person a tank-filler or a tank-emptier? Overall, does he drain or enrich your sense of you?
If you want a happier life, hang out with tank fillers, who can give of themselves the things that really matter in great relationships: attention, appreciation, approval, affection, encouragement, acceptance, validation, comfort, joy.. people who support you to be the best version of you.
If you want a miserable life, hang out with tank emptiers, who will give you criticism, envy, competition, resentment, recrimination, spite, backstabbing and who leap on every chance to rain on your parade and use your resources for their own benefit.
It may be that reading this you think that some people are both. They aren't.
