Cyanide wrote:
I'm guessing a few more of us American-born 18-year-olds desperate for a job would actually have one. Sure, it'd be at Taco Bell or Mickey D's, but it's a job nonetheless.
The opposite is more likely. The jobs would be priced out of the market or destroyed by the Fed with interest rate hikes.
Maybe you do not understand some simple business realties of alot of immigrant jobs. A farmer can spend alot money per acre
on herbicides or he can potential spend a lot less using immigrants to hoe the fields(certified organic to

) A farmer could buy expensive capital equipment that could do the jobs of many immigrants to. In both cases there would be net job loss and food prices would likely be higher. You might have a snowballs chance at one of the few union jobs that made the chemicals or equipment. But I'm fairly certain China will be picking up increased demand
in those areas since those things can be outsourced.
In Oregon, our minimum wage is $7.80/hr, which is pretty damn good (best in the nation). There are also plenty of people willing to work so if nothing else they can have spending money. Plenty of US citizens are also willing to do grunt work. My dad does construction, and one of my friends is a drywaller. We wouldn't have such a "dire need" for immigrants if we'd just make the unemployed take these jobs (or threaten to cut their welfare and unemployment if they don't).