There was a bit of a Mama Mia type of situation generations before me. Granted, with two potential fathers rather than three. And far less eventful than that film. 
An ancestor of mine, she was rumoured to have a had a fling with a travelling musician. A minor celebrity not exactly known for being the relationship type.
Shortly after, she met and fell in love with another man whom she married months later, then she found out she was pregnant not long after.
Granted, we don't even know if the rumours about the fling were true. We'll never know. It's a mystery lost to time. 
_________________
Support human artists!
26. Near the spectrum but not on it.