ThatRedHairedGrrl wrote:
That always bugs me. The implication is that there is actually more than one power that people can be drawing from when they perform supernatural feats, and that even if those feats have a good end - like healing - they're evil if they derive their power from the 'wrong' source. Surely if there's any source for such power, there can only be one? (Anything else really has to be dualism, which was heresy last time I looked.)
Oh, come on. Have you never read the Wheel of Time series, with
saidar and
saidin, the male and female sources of power, one of which has been corrupted by the Dark One and drives anyone who uses it mad? Or the Amber Chronicles, with the Pattern magic vs. the Chaos magic? Or seen Star Wars, with the Light and Dark Sides of the Force?
Quote:
The flipside is that things which are morally evil can be called 'good' if they derive their power from the 'right' place
Not really.
Quote:
But if it's against the person's will, this is also black magic.
Prayer and magic are different. Prayer is a request of a supernatural entity. (Of course, not all prayer is petitionary, but that's off topic.) Magic is an attempt to directly use supernatural power (at least I assume that's what Wiccans mean by the term). Also, you are assuming that Wiccan standards for what spells are acceptable will completely overlap with Christian standards for what prayers are acceptable. I doubt that the Christian and Wiccan understanding of free will is identical.
Quote:
Praying for people's death - well, don't even go there, but I have heard of people doing it, people who called themselves Christians. Excuse me?

I hope you heard wrong. Asking God to carry out evil deeds for you is at least borderline blasphemy.
Quote:
Quote:
Remember, the devil can appear as an angel of light
So, um, pardon me for asking, but...what do angels appear as, then?
Angels of light, maybe? Remember, the Christian understanding is that demons were once angels, it's just that they rebelled against God, so now they're evil and hate everybody, whereas they once were good and loved everybody. Demons are bad angels.
_________________
"A dead thing can go with the stream, but only a living thing can go against it." --G. K. Chesterton