Man had sex with 15 year old autistic girl; jailed

Post Reply New Topic

It was not his daughter it was the daughter of a mother he met.

It would not make any difference, it would still be illegal under US law.

Umm, she called him his daddy?

Clearly the guy is a prick and clearly he took advantage of her, whether people want to admit it or not.

Whether it was consensual or not, I don't know, but the guy is still a prick (I am a male by the way). I know enough about the way men think to know this.

I would not have sex with someone I knew to be 15 years old. I would not allow her to call me "my daddy." I mean come on, it is sickening.

There is a point here where the woman's views need to be taken into consideration, but my intuition tells me he deserved what he got. There is something to this idea of desexualing disabled people (I suppose?) but I just don't buy it in this case. He was in the wrong, he knew he was in the wrong, and he did it anyway.

US law wouldn't have made any difference if he did it in another country

*facepalm* Really, now

A paedophile is an adult that is sexually attracted to a pre-pubescent CHILD.
And a 15 year old is not a CHILD and it is a normal age for a young person to understand and want sex. It does not matter if she is autistic, I find the de-sexualisation of the disabled an insult, anyone with a disability especially a mental one whether or not it affects intelligence is not allowed to have a sexuality. And if anyone has sex with a grown up disabled person, such as an autistic they will be demonised by everyone else. Disabled people should not be treated as babies, and neither should 15 year olds.

The age of consent is 16 in the UK as well as Britain's Crown Dependencies and Overseas Territories. As she was 15, she was near enough the age of consent on that level and whilst sexual activity does occur and is illegal, it is generally not acted upon legally unless the younger partner raises a complaint or it is found to be abusive.

As has been said previously, it's really about the girl's ability to consent rather than her age.



I understand where you are coming from. In most cases, yes, it is an insult if their disabilities do not stop them being able to exercise their self-determination on whom they wish to sleep with. There are special disability organisations that exist here in Britain to help disabled people find partners. But I think people worry because people with mental/cognitive difficulties can so easily be exploited and abused by those with the balance of power. In this case, the sex sounds like it was abusive.