Is Anti Zionism Anti Semitism in my opinion the answer is no

Post Reply New Topic

Those Europeans were hated everywhere they went. My family wandered around in shame throughout Europe, and was hated everywhere for keeping their tradition. So why should they try and keep integrating elsewhere? If Europe doesn't want Jews, Jews will survive with no Europe.

My family "chose not to integrate" after years of antisemitism, violence, racism and bigotry, and after 3 years of hell at Auschwitz she was still unwanted in her home village.

Racist? If saying I belong to a nation is racist, then I'm racist. Zionism says nothing racist, as I said, the first Zionist was married to a non-Jew. He wanted to keep Judaism as a distinct tradition and nationality alive.

Claim on a land? My ancestors lived there, and we haven't forgotten our tradition and connection to this land for over 2000 years, so yes, I have a claim. The Palestinians have a claim as well - they live so close to these sites, they should be able to visit them. Everyone has the right to claim that they feel at home wherever they feel so. Zionists did not want to kick the Arabs out, not the majority of them at least.

Well than we need to clarify if we are opposed to POLITICAL zionism or CULTURAL zionism.I have no issue with jews moving to palestine and neither did the Palestinians until the were forced out of their homes.So maybe we all need to recognize the difference

Though truly i think its rascist to divide religions up geographically,that only polarizes an already divided world.

Zionism does not mean the same thing to all people.

I believe that the Jewish people constitute a nation in the older sense of that word. I support the existence of the State of Israel as fulling a need for a modern nation state that provides an international legal presence for the Jewish nation.

But that does not mean that I uncritically support every decision of the government of the State of Israel. Israel is a Parliamentary democracy, and at the root of every Parliamentary democracy is the understanding that there is no single solution to any of the challenges facing a government. Accordingly, it is entirely possible to be a Zionist, but to disapprove of the policy of Israel on the West Bank, for example. It is entirely possible to be a Zionist, but to support the creation of a nation state that provides an international legal presence for the Palestinian nation. (That should have been Jordan, perhaps, but that possibility is long since gone).

Similarly, it is possible to oppose the policies of the government of Israel without believing that the State of Israel ought not properly to exist.

In my view, if you say, "Israel is wrong to blockade Gaza," that is neither inherently anti-Zionist, nor is it anit-Semitic. But, if you say, "Israel is an illegitimate state," then that statement is more clearly anti-Zionist. But it's not until you get to formulae like "Jews have no right to a homeland," or Jews, "can choose to integrate themselves anywhere they choose to live," that anti-Semitism begins to rear its ugly head.

As sartresue correctly points out, these concepts are not one and the same--but they are often fellow travellers.