Klingons vs Vulcans psychological traits

Post Reply New Topic

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD2A7L2h74I[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zEGRO0lkAc[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhV43JiGiSE[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UcYnd377WE[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ITXaUF_K7zk[/youtube]

Vulcan

75%

Federation

60%

Borg

55%

Dominion

55%

Cardassian

35%

Romulan

25%

Ferengi

20%

Klingon

10%

You Scored as Nurse Chapel
You are Nurse Chapel. You are very soft-hearted and need to protect yourself from hurt. You are not very lucky in relationships, perhaps because you choose cold and unemotional people as mates. You are very caring, though, and should probably choose a career in therapy or medicine. You are attracted to intelligence, but don't let yourself be led around by those you consider your superiors. You have many of your own resources to rely on, and will be very successful if you can stand up for yourself and have pride in your abilities.



Spock

64%

Nurse Chapel

64%

Uhura

61%

Pavel Chekov

32%

Captain Kirk

25%

Dr. McCoy

21%

Montgomery Scott--"Scotty"

21%

Hikaru Sulu

14%


Great now I'm going to get obsessed with all these Star trek quizzes

species test

You Scored as Vulcan
Congratulations. You must be very smart to be a Vulcan.



Vulcan

88%

Human

68%

Romulan

33%

Cardassian

30%

Klingon

25%

Borg

8%

I took the one on Quibblo...and got Betazoid.



Maybe there is something to "intense world theory"....

As far as "which character" (also Quibblo): McCoy.

Well, Vulcans are actually crazy as all hell innately, it's just that they're indoctrinated since birth to follow a certain type of logic, otherwise all they do is kill each other. It's ironic that the Romulans are actually more sane (they're kinda like mildly paranoid humans).

The Klingons on the other hand, actually build themselves up with all the bravado and viking stuff from an early age; without that, they're not much different to basic Federation humans (perhaps a little more aggressive innately, but not too much more).

(I like the Ferengi.)

A little on topic but aren't Vulcans and Romulans distant cousins, in terms of race?

If we were to keep it simple I'd always imagine the breakdown to work like this.

Ferengi Obsessive compulsive, hyper anxious.

Klingons ADHD, Borderline, and Bipolar.

Betazoids Hyper empathetic, hyper social.

Cardassians, paranoid, narcissistic, anxious(ocd), and Psychopathic

Vulcans, autism.
\
Romulans, narcissism, psychopathy.


The vulcan romunlan split however is the truly interesting question.

I've come up with a few theory of the pre logic vulcans.

1) Vulcans were just like the current Romulans, however over time historical revisionism portrayed natural Vulcanians as mentally unstable.

2) Vulcans and Romulans were split along physiological lines dividing two group by some form of spectrum(autistism?)

3) Romulans after leaving vulcan interbred with another species bringing stability to their people.

4) Romulans underwent chemical treaments to control their emotions in contrast to the vulcans that underwent some form of therapy(logic.)

Interesting to see how many people got Federation, Vulcan and Borg as their top three. I ended up as Federation, with Vulcan and Borg tied for second. As far as which character, I thought I might be Spock, but I was Geordi first and Data second. Intruiging...