Yes, definitely. I don’t remember when it started, but when I was a teenager I used to have tons of magazine pin-ups in my room. I always felt like they were watching me, but I was able to logically convince myself that they weren’t real, so I didn’t have to take them down or anything. I still have the feeling to this day, but fortunately logic still prevails.
I read somewhere once that this was a sign of schizophrenia, but in that case you wouldn’t be able to logically override the thought. You would seriously, honestly believe that the person in the picture was alive and watching you.
When I read that most auties process faces with the same area of the brain that they process objects, a theory came to me. My brain might see a face as an object, but just like my brain knows a tree from a book, it knows a face from a tree (if that makes any sense). And since I’ve had to teach myself that this face-object-thing = a person with thoughts and feelings, perhaps when my brain sees a face – even on paper - it still wants to believe that that face still equals any other face – ie: a real person. But just like I know I can’t smell a flower in a picture, I can tell myself that a face in a picture can’t really see me.
But it’s definitely all in the eyes. If the person’s eyes aren’t looking into the camera, then I don’t get that feeling at all. I don’t like being looked at by REAL eyes, so I guess it makes sense that I wouldn’t like to be looked at by paper eyes either.