pensieve wrote:
I think it does stem from a childhood of having my name bellowed out by very angry parents, teachers and parents of other children.
This just reminded me of something I saw recently. A client of mine was dealing with her small daughter, who is three or four years old. The daughter was having a bit of a difficult morning, tearful and non-cooperative, and then she wouldn't let another child play with one of her toys.
The mother squatted down and started saying "Amy! Amy! We share in this house! Amy? Amy?" looking her in the eyes to try to engage her and impress the lesson on her. Although she wasn't speaking angrily or shouting, she WAS very emphatic and expressing shock and of course a certain amount of disapproval of the child's behavior.
The poor kid started saying "Don't say 'AMY'! Don't say 'AMY'! Don't say 'Amy'!"
It's funny but I SOOOOO related to wanting to tell a person to stop saying my name when unhappy with me!
I knew it felt like an attack (mildly) to the child because her own name was being repeated by a stern parent unhappy with a behavior.
It leads me to wonder if parents and teachers should be sparing about using a child's name under these circumstances (anger, lesson-teaching, disapproval of an action) --- and not just AS children but any child? It does start to make one's own name feel like a "telling off." I'm 52, had this as a child, and my own name STILL makes me wince when said under certain circumstances.
.