Aspie son just left fist-sized hole in our hallway wall

Page 4 of 5 [ 70 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next

granatelli
Deinonychus
Deinonychus

User avatar

Joined: 31 Mar 2009
Age: 64
Gender: Male
Posts: 308

03 Sep 2009, 5:51 pm

If you're trying to say a teenage boy with AS has about as much sense or self control as a baby sitting in a dirty diaper that IMO, is not a very flattering comparison.


Spokane_Girl wrote:
granatelli wrote:
Silvervarg wrote:
Yes you should have, as you did. Don't let his outburst scare you. It does not matter how many hormones are running amok in his body or what the other kids are doing to him at school, it's not a right to be angry and break things. Ever.


Agreed. The behavior was unacceptable. Quite frankly I'm shocked to see so many people responding in a "Oh, that's normal/I did that and most teenage boys are like that" attitude. It's not normal and most teenage boys don't act that way.

Look at it this way. If an NT student got so mad at an AS student (because of some minor thing) that he glared at the AS student and then punched a hole in the wall would you still think it was no big deal? Obviously there is a form of intimidation going on here.

Unacceptable.



I don't think they're excusing the behavior by saying it's normal. Yes it is normal but it's normal misbehavior and it's unacceptable. Just like it's normal for a baby to smear feces on themselves or put it in their mouths but that doesn't make it okay so you stop them. It's also normal for a two and three year old to throw a tantrum to get their way but that is still unacceptable and the parents just don't give in on them and they ignore it. Just like it's normal for babies to put anything in their mouths but that doesn't mean you should accept them putting things in their mouths they could choke on or swallow.



mechanicalgirl39
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Apr 2009
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,340

03 Sep 2009, 6:06 pm

bhetti wrote:
in my experience school administrators and most teachers are useless. the only way my son got help in the system was by getting an IEP. now if an incident happens because of bullying, it is no longer laid at my son's feet, it gets assessed for cause. before the IEP, my son was labeled a troublemaker so when he freaked out over being picked on at school the school ALWAYS sided with the bullies and my son always got suspended.

I tried homeschooling for a while, just because it was better than expulsions, but it didn't really help my son or me since I couldn't support us financially as an unpaid teacher and I have social issues myself.


Exactly the same here.

A girl once tried to beat the s**t out of me. I fought back and injured her. Guess who got in trouble. Clue: she did not have ASD.

Then there was the time I slapped someone for grabbing my breasts. Guess who got in trouble.


_________________
'You're so cold, but you feel alive
Lay your hands on me, one last time' (Breaking Benjamin)


03 Sep 2009, 6:14 pm

granatelli wrote:
If you're trying to say a teenage boy with AS has about as much sense or self control as a baby sitting in a dirty diaper that IMO, is not a very flattering comparison.


Spokane_Girl wrote:
granatelli wrote:
Silvervarg wrote:
Yes you should have, as you did. Don't let his outburst scare you. It does not matter how many hormones are running amok in his body or what the other kids are doing to him at school, it's not a right to be angry and break things. Ever.


Agreed. The behavior was unacceptable. Quite frankly I'm shocked to see so many people responding in a "Oh, that's normal/I did that and most teenage boys are like that" attitude. It's not normal and most teenage boys don't act that way.

Look at it this way. If an NT student got so mad at an AS student (because of some minor thing) that he glared at the AS student and then punched a hole in the wall would you still think it was no big deal? Obviously there is a form of intimidation going on here.

Unacceptable.



I don't think they're excusing the behavior by saying it's normal. Yes it is normal but it's normal misbehavior and it's unacceptable. Just like it's normal for a baby to smear feces on themselves or put it in their mouths but that doesn't make it okay so you stop them. It's also normal for a two and three year old to throw a tantrum to get their way but that is still unacceptable and the parents just don't give in on them and they ignore it. Just like it's normal for babies to put anything in their mouths but that doesn't mean you should accept them putting things in their mouths they could choke on or swallow.



Funny how none aspies take my posts out of context or misunderstand me. It's like we both speak a different language.



03 Sep 2009, 6:15 pm

mechanicalgirl39 wrote:
bhetti wrote:
in my experience school administrators and most teachers are useless. the only way my son got help in the system was by getting an IEP. now if an incident happens because of bullying, it is no longer laid at my son's feet, it gets assessed for cause. before the IEP, my son was labeled a troublemaker so when he freaked out over being picked on at school the school ALWAYS sided with the bullies and my son always got suspended.

I tried homeschooling for a while, just because it was better than expulsions, but it didn't really help my son or me since I couldn't support us financially as an unpaid teacher and I have social issues myself.


Exactly the same here.

A girl once tried to beat the sh** out of me. I fought back and injured her. Guess who got in trouble. Clue: she did not have ASD.

Then there was the time I slapped someone for grabbing my breasts. Guess who got in trouble.


You?



RPM
Raven
Raven

User avatar

Joined: 10 Jul 2006
Age: 46
Gender: Male
Posts: 119
Location: Michigan

03 Sep 2009, 6:22 pm

Spokane_Girl wrote:
granatelli wrote:
If you're trying to say a teenage boy with AS has about as much sense or self control as a baby sitting in a dirty diaper that IMO, is not a very flattering comparison.


Spokane_Girl wrote:
granatelli wrote:
Silvervarg wrote:
Yes you should have, as you did. Don't let his outburst scare you. It does not matter how many hormones are running amok in his body or what the other kids are doing to him at school, it's not a right to be angry and break things. Ever.


Agreed. The behavior was unacceptable. Quite frankly I'm shocked to see so many people responding in a "Oh, that's normal/I did that and most teenage boys are like that" attitude. It's not normal and most teenage boys don't act that way.

Look at it this way. If an NT student got so mad at an AS student (because of some minor thing) that he glared at the AS student and then punched a hole in the wall would you still think it was no big deal? Obviously there is a form of intimidation going on here.

Unacceptable.



I don't think they're excusing the behavior by saying it's normal. Yes it is normal but it's normal misbehavior and it's unacceptable. Just like it's normal for a baby to smear feces on themselves or put it in their mouths but that doesn't make it okay so you stop them. It's also normal for a two and three year old to throw a tantrum to get their way but that is still unacceptable and the parents just don't give in on them and they ignore it. Just like it's normal for babies to put anything in their mouths but that doesn't mean you should accept them putting things in their mouths they could choke on or swallow.



Funny how none aspies take my posts out of context or misunderstand me. It's like we both speak a different language.


I hear you, I remember in a chatroom when I said I cannot afford to move within my own state unless my house sells or I get a butt pounding job and I am on the spectrum myself and well another guy on the spectrum suggested I move to New Jersey and I was like "if I cannot afford to move within my own state how am I gonna afford to move to a state that my Great-Great-Great Grandpa Silverthorne moved out of)."



ooOoOoOAnaOoOoOoo
Veteran
Veteran

Joined: 18 Jun 2008
Gender: Female
Posts: 12,265

03 Sep 2009, 6:23 pm

Let me reiterate - Punching stuff isn't that uncommon for kids or teens. Just Google "teens punching walls", "teenage boys punching doors and walls", or "teenagers hitting walls and making holes in them", and see how many responses you get. It hasn't much to be with one's neurology, but more to do with how one channels one's anger.
It doesn't make them horrible people.

To the OP: have you thought about enrolling him in boxing lessons, maybe? That's a more acceptable way to channel anger.



mechanicalgirl39
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Apr 2009
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,340

03 Sep 2009, 6:58 pm

Spokane_Girl wrote:
mechanicalgirl39 wrote:
bhetti wrote:
in my experience school administrators and most teachers are useless. the only way my son got help in the system was by getting an IEP. now if an incident happens because of bullying, it is no longer laid at my son's feet, it gets assessed for cause. before the IEP, my son was labeled a troublemaker so when he freaked out over being picked on at school the school ALWAYS sided with the bullies and my son always got suspended.

I tried homeschooling for a while, just because it was better than expulsions, but it didn't really help my son or me since I couldn't support us financially as an unpaid teacher and I have social issues myself.


Exactly the same here.

A girl once tried to beat the sh** out of me. I fought back and injured her. Guess who got in trouble. Clue: she did not have ASD.

Then there was the time I slapped someone for grabbing my breasts. Guess who got in trouble.


You?


Yup.


_________________
'You're so cold, but you feel alive
Lay your hands on me, one last time' (Breaking Benjamin)


bhetti
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 May 2009
Age: 61
Gender: Female
Posts: 874

03 Sep 2009, 7:13 pm

granatelli wrote:
First off, I don’t appreciate that exclamation points were added to my “unacceptable”. It makes it sound hysterical and panicky, which was not the way I meant it.

I didn't add explanation points to "your" unaccepables. you weren't the only one who used the word.

maybe I should have quoted every use of the word unacceptable so it wouldn't look like I was singling you out for that. I quoted you for being shocked over the responses from other posters. there seemed to be an expectation on your part that everyone should condemn the kid for punching a hole through the wall. reading that over and over was starting to get to me. his mom has some specific concerns, so what good is it for a bunch of people to post how unacceptable his behavior is?

plus I was still pissed about the post that equated punching a wall with punching a person.



mechanicalgirl39
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Apr 2009
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,340

03 Sep 2009, 7:20 pm

By the way, some advice for people with anger problems (this works well for me anyway).

If you're close to losing it, keep as many of your muscles completely limp as possible. I have NO idea how this works, but seizing up your muscles in anger seems to send some kind of feedback to the brain which just makes you more angry.


_________________
'You're so cold, but you feel alive
Lay your hands on me, one last time' (Breaking Benjamin)


bhetti
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 May 2009
Age: 61
Gender: Female
Posts: 874

03 Sep 2009, 7:21 pm

mechanicalgirl39 wrote:
bhetti wrote:
in my experience school administrators and most teachers are useless. the only way my son got help in the system was by getting an IEP. now if an incident happens because of bullying, it is no longer laid at my son's feet, it gets assessed for cause. before the IEP, my son was labeled a troublemaker so when he freaked out over being picked on at school the school ALWAYS sided with the bullies and my son always got suspended.

I tried homeschooling for a while, just because it was better than expulsions, but it didn't really help my son or me since I couldn't support us financially as an unpaid teacher and I have social issues myself.


Exactly the same here.

A girl once tried to beat the sh** out of me. I fought back and injured her. Guess who got in trouble. Clue: she did not have ASD.

Then there was the time I slapped someone for grabbing my breasts. Guess who got in trouble.

I was a peaceful person until 15 or so when a girl started hassling me at a bus stop. I moved to another seat and she followed me, issuing insults the whole time. I ignored her until she burned me on the arm with a cigarette. then she pretty much got everything I had, and when passers-by pulled me off her she was covered with blood. then they threatened me to call the cops on me.

after that I didn't tend to want to take anyone's crap, including my mother's. she would regularly push me into meltdowns, and if I screamed at her she would hit me in the head with her fists. after I started fighting back she quit doing it.



marshall
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 14 Apr 2007
Gender: Male
Posts: 10,752
Location: Turkey

03 Sep 2009, 8:09 pm

granatelli wrote:
First off, I don’t appreciate that exclamation points were added to my “unacceptable”. It makes it sound hysterical and panicky, which was not the way I meant it.

Secondly, I did offer advise to the mother;

“What's done is done though & I would not counter the anger with more anger. Today I would sit him down & explain to him why it was wrong, why that kind of behavior is unacceptable in a civilized world and what he can expect to have happen if it ever happens again. Work with him on, so you both agree how it should be handled in the future if it's really important that he does what you say. A five minute buffer, whatever. Something you can both live with. Then stick to it. Aspies understand rules, correct? : )”

Whether one poster or not seemed to think it was “normal” teenage boy behavior is debatable. Enough people chimed in to make it seem it was acceptable & the norm;

“Some Aspies have a rather powerful rage.”

“I punched holes in the wall all the time as a teenager. I still do at times.”

“While I'm overall a peaceful person, I'm not a very relaxed person, and have also put holes into walls; there's currently a hole in my sliding closet door, which I put tape on to avoid insects from getting inside.”

“I did that once too when my siblings decided to play a joke and lock me downstairs.My older sister ignored my hollerin, so I got mad and punched a hole in the wall.”

“I punched a hole in a door, I got to change it myself.”

“I kicked a hole in the bathroom wall when enraged while wearing only sandals. I also dented the drywall with my knuckles on at least one occasion, and also once threw a book through my bedroom window. Granted, it took a lot to enrage me to that extent, but yes, it's something I know well.”

“I've had my share of holes in the wall. My old house had at least 20, most of them from me.”

“i got so mad i went to my room and started to punch my door until there was a hole big enough to fit my head through.”

“What he did wasn't THAT violent. And HEY, he didn't touch YOU.”

“Do you realize how many teenagers punch holes in things? This is not uncommon behaviour. Sounds like an anger management issue.”

“I have slammed my bedroom door so many times during meltdowns, that it broke the wood frame.”

“I did that last month. I never did stop this, although it happens a lot less. I have a fresh supply of wall mesh and putty on stand by, as well as paint the colours of all my walls. It's an understatement to say "I can get angry at times".

“It may not be ideal, but it is far from unacceptable.”

“I've done it. I usually feel really stupid afterward though since the walls in my house are like hard as cement.(not like our new Chinese drywall.) Lucky to not break my hand.”

“I'd say it is an AS related thing. We have one HELL of a powerful rage on us when triggered. Not all of us are prone to those meltdowns, but a good proportion are.”

“I have:

- pounded a dent in a car door with my fist. Amazingly, I did not fracture my hand.

- smashed in my computer screen with my fist...I loved that computer otherwise. ”

“I put holes in walls when I was a teenager. I already knew it was unacceptable but I did it anyways. I often reached the point where I was so angry that I don't care about the consequences of my actions.”

Am I the only one that can see the pattern here?


bhetti wrote:
granatelli wrote:
Agreed. The behavior was unacceptable. Quite frankly I'm shocked to see so many people responding in a "Oh, that's normal/I did that and most teenage boys are like that" attitude. It's not normal and most teenage boys don't act that way.
I'm not seeing that at all. I'm not going to read back over the replies, but I think only one person actually said it was normal teenage boy behavior.

even though a lot of us empathize with the situation, we aren't trying to excuse it, so don't assume acceptance that isn't there.

kid punched a hole in the wall. running around yelling "unacceptable! unacceptable!" doesn't do anything except make you look holy. it doesn't actually help mom at all. I'm sure she's not stupid and wants to help her son handle anger better. that was always my goal when my son would go off the deep end. I also had fears of what he would do in the future and my son needed a lot of help to channel his anger.

I think people have in general been empathetic and made some constructive suggestions for how to deal with it. I'd much rather come to a forum with that attitude than one that focuses on how messed up my son is and equates him to a criminal. I get enough of that out there.


I don't see what you're point is. Only one person said it was "normal teenage behavior" and another said it was "far from unacceptable". People who can relate to the anger displayed in the OP are going to respond in greater numbers than those who can't. That's all that's been demonstrated.

Plus most teenagers who have punched holes in walls already know that what they did is considered unacceptable. All you're doing here is demonizing and belittling people. I assume you're so perfect that you've never lost your temper or acted uncivilized. Good for you.



Tory_canuck
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2009
Age: 39
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,373
Location: Red Deer, Alberta, Canada

04 Sep 2009, 2:38 am

mechanicalgirl39 wrote:
Spokane_Girl wrote:
mechanicalgirl39 wrote:
bhetti wrote:
in my experience school administrators and most teachers are useless. the only way my son got help in the system was by getting an IEP. now if an incident happens because of bullying, it is no longer laid at my son's feet, it gets assessed for cause. before the IEP, my son was labeled a troublemaker so when he freaked out over being picked on at school the school ALWAYS sided with the bullies and my son always got suspended.

I tried homeschooling for a while, just because it was better than expulsions, but it didn't really help my son or me since I couldn't support us financially as an unpaid teacher and I have social issues myself.


Exactly the same here.

A girl once tried to beat the sh** out of me. I fought back and injured her. Guess who got in trouble. Clue: she did not have ASD.

Then there was the time I slapped someone for grabbing my breasts. Guess who got in trouble.


You?


Yup.



If some facist turd teacher or whatever pr-bully scum gave me flak for defending myself against someone grabbing me in such a manner or attacking me, all I'd have to do is tell my dad, and he'd deal with that authority figure and theyd wish they didn't side with the offending person. :evil:


_________________
Honour over deciet, merit over luck, courage over popularity, duty over entitlement...dont let the cliques fool you for they have no honour...only superficial deceit.

ALBERTAN...and DAMN PROUD OF IT!!


Tory_canuck
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2009
Age: 39
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,373
Location: Red Deer, Alberta, Canada

04 Sep 2009, 2:39 am

If some creepy turd grabbed my breasts, Id do more than slap em...let's just say, theyd think twice before grabbing anything ever again.


_________________
Honour over deciet, merit over luck, courage over popularity, duty over entitlement...dont let the cliques fool you for they have no honour...only superficial deceit.

ALBERTAN...and DAMN PROUD OF IT!!


mechanicalgirl39
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Apr 2009
Age: 35
Gender: Female
Posts: 2,340

04 Sep 2009, 7:19 am

Quote:
Plus most teenagers who have punched holes in walls already know that what they did is considered unacceptable. All you're doing here is demonizing and belittling people. I assume you're so perfect that you've never lost your temper or acted uncivilized. Good for you.


Agreed. Most people have done it at some point in their life. My mother once threw a banana at the wall because she was so frustrated at not being able to stop my brother's meltdowns, should we demonize her instead of understanding??


_________________
'You're so cold, but you feel alive
Lay your hands on me, one last time' (Breaking Benjamin)


Silvervarg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 25 Jan 2009
Age: 37
Gender: Male
Posts: 787
Location: Sweden

04 Sep 2009, 9:19 am

mechanicalgirl39 wrote:
By the way, some advice for people with anger problems (this works well for me anyway).

If you're close to losing it, keep as many of your muscles completely limp as possible. I have NO idea how this works, but seizing up your muscles in anger seems to send some kind of feedback to the brain which just makes you more angry.

Yupp, that's why I hug my dog. :D


_________________
Sing songs. Songs sung. Samsung.


Zeno
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Jun 2006
Age: 52
Gender: Male
Posts: 633
Location: Singapore

04 Sep 2009, 10:54 am

I have not read through all the posts on this thread, but it sounds like you have correctly diagnosed the cause of the problem as his going back to school. The hell that awaits an Aspie kid in school with taunting students and bullying teachers can be unbearable. Punching a hole in the wall may just be his way of expressing his rage at having to return to an environment that never stops hurting him.

It is of course never acceptable to be violent, but many people on the spectrum are known to behave violently on occasion; either to others or to themselves. Negative emotions like anger or fear is often mishandled by the autistic brain. Add to this the stresses of dealing with a hostile environment where the aggressor towards the Aspie is often rewarded, and the result can be a child who grows up seeking violence as a normative expression of inner rage. Such outbursts can temporarily alleviate the sense of futile loathing and hatred, but none of the root causes will be solved.

If you are worried about your son growing up to be a violent young man who may hurt you or others in your family, then you need to take those hunches seriously. If school is not working out, consider homeschooling him. Many Aspie kids are intelligent autodidacts who are probably better off learning on their own than dealing with a teacher who does not know much anyway. Unlike others, I do not believe that forcing your son to socialize is necessarily in his best interests. If he cannot do it, then it must be recognized that he has this impairment. Forcing him to learn how to adjust to society may actually just break him instead of developing any worthwhile skills.