trollcatman wrote:
You burn more calories if you are heavier? Doesn't that depend on whether the weight is fat or muscle? I'd think that fat would insulate you and therefore needing fewer calories.
Regardless of if the weight is fat or muscle, you do burn more if you're heavier. It takes more work to function the heavier you are. If nothing else, your heart burns at least a few hundred calories every day.
The only way I've EVER managed to lose weight was to just stop eating. I could eat iceberg lettuce salad for two meals a day, a teaspoon of dressing and no croutons, and skip breakfast and still gain weight. Fasting for 40 days (water fasting, no supplements), I initially didn't lose ANY weight for about a week, and then it was somewhere around 1 lb./day for 4 or 5 weeks. The very last week I barely lost 0.5 lb., and I'd gone from 230 to 152 and really didn't have much fat left to lose by that point. It will be 2 years this December since I started that, and I've put 20 lb. back on. Generally I don't eat more than 24 oz. food on any given day, fast at least once a week and sometimes up to 3 days a week, and walk 2.5 miles/day for 5 days a week, and since I have my 2-yo with me that takes about 1.5 hours every day. I've just recently started doing 1 chin-up after each lap, which sends needle-like pain shooting up my elbows, but I think MAYBE I'm starting to grow some biceps?idk. The thing is, once I put on weight, it's almost impossible to get rid of it, and I'd love nothing more than to drop the 20 lb. I've gained. Overall I feel good fasting, I usually focus intensely on something to take my mind off the hunger and keep at it until my fast is over.
I've never as long as I can remember needed more than 500 cal. At the risk of TMI here, I also have extremely slow bowel movements?like, once a week or less BM. So I'll typically gain up to 5 lb. and literally lose it overnight. I gain up to 8 lb. DURING the day, and it's almost all water, and depending on how well I'm keeping my salt consumption up, I MIGHT end up with a morning weight lower than the previous morning. If I discuss my weight, I'm normally referring to my morning weight since it's the lowest. If I don't keep my water up on the weekends, I'll lose roughly about another 3 lb before ending my fast on Saturday evening. Sometimes I'll maintain that weight through Sunday, but somehow I really put on a lot of weight on Mondays.
My worst days for maintaining weight are Wednesdays. I practically live at church all day on Wednesdays, so there's a meal at noon Bible study, a repeat for evening Bible study if I don't go for junk food with the youth group (I play in the band), I may/may not eat an apple when I get home at 8:30 at night. For the last two weeks in a row, I've sharply cut how much I eat on Wednesdays and so far I've been able to maintain my weight rather than ballooning my usual 5 lb./week.